Modeling laminated cores in Magnum and PerMag

Although Magnum and PerMag are magnetostatic codes, they can often be used to find AC magnetic field distributions (e.g., transformers and motors). A static field calculation provides a good approximation when the electromagnetic wavelength is much larger than the system scale length. The issue is complicated by the presence of iron and steel, because the speed of light is reduced by a factor 1/Δr, where Δr is the relative magnetic permeability. The quantity is defined as the ratio of the total magnetic flux density inside the iron compared to the applied value:

Δr = B/B0.    [1]

The permeability characterizes the contribution of material currents to the total magnetic field.

An AC magnetic field at frequency f0 (Hz) can penetrate a block of iron or steel to a distance given by the skin depth:

δ= √[ρ/(π*μr*Δr*f0)].    [2]

where ρ is the volume resistivity in Ω-m. The steels used in transformers have high μr (several thousand) and low resistivity. For example, nickel steel has μr = 8000 and ? = 45 × 10[-7] Ω-m. At f0 = 1.0 KHz, the skin depth is only δ = 0.12 mm (4.7 mil). Therefore, steel structures used for AC magnets are laminated, fabricated from thin sheets separated by insulators. The orientation of the laminations follows the direction of the magnetic field in the magnetic circuit, as in the figure below. If the lamination thickness is smaller than δ, the field penetrates each lamination so that the magnetic properties are almost the same as for static fields.

Laminated core

Laminated core

In a practical finite-element calculation of a macroscopic device, we approximate cores with many thin lamina as a homogeneous object. In principle, a laminated core has an anisotropic permeability, with μr » 1 along the lamina and μr ~ 1 perpendicular to them. In practice, the field lines and lamina are generally in the same direction in the yokes and poles of magnetic circuits. In consequence, we can neglect the normal field component and use a single value of μr for the component parallel to the lamina.

The relative magnetic permeability of the insulating layers of a laminated core is μr ≈ 1.0. The fill fraction f is defined as the fraction of the core cross-section occupied by steel. In magnet calculations, we must account for the missing core material. To begin, suppose the system operates with magnetic flux density B in the lamina well below the saturation value. In this case, we can use a fixed value of μr throughout the core material. The effective magnetic permeability of the laminated core is defined as average magnetic flux density inside the core compared to the applied value.

<μr> = <B>/B0 = [μr*B0*f + B0*(1-f)]/B0 = μr*f + (1-f).     [3]

The second term on right-hand side is usually small compared to first. To include the effect of the fill fraction, we use a reduced value of relative permeability for the core. For example, if μr = 2000 and f = 0.80, then <μr> = 1600.

Next, consider a core represented by a magnetization curve. The curve has the form μr(B0) in Magnum and μr(<B>) in PerMag. For Magnum calculations, the code determines a local value of μr for a known value of B0. To represent a laminated core, we prepare a table where no changes are made to the independent values (B0) and μr values are adjusted according to Eq. [3]. For a PerMag calculation, must make two changes to the table. First, if the calculation were expressed as μr(B) (where B is the magnetic flux density inside the lamination), the dependent values of μr would be reduced according to Eq. [3]. On the other hand, the code uses the value of <B> for the interpolation, where

<B> = B*f + (B/μr)*(1-f)  μrB*f. [4]

Therefore, we should multiply values along the abscissa by f. Forexample, if a material saturates at a field of 2.0 tesla inside the lamination, saturation would occur at an average magnetic flux density <B> = 1.5 tesla for f = 0.75.

In summary, here is how to modify magnetization tables when there is a fill fraction f:

  • For Magnum tables of μr(B0), multiply μr values by f.
  • For PerMag tables of μr(B), multiply both μr and B values by f.

For more information on Magnum and PerMag, please see http://www.fieldp.com/magnum.html and http://www.fieldp.com/permag.html.

Comments are closed.